And it doesnt really work.

First is the matter of the hosts themselves: Ben Lyons, the 26-year-old film expert from E!

Entertainment, and Ben Mankiewicz, the 41-year-old host for Turner Classic Movies.

Image

Unlike Siskel and Ebert, neither of these men are newspaper film critics.

And then theres the shows hasty editing.

The program moves at a bam-bam-bam pace that feels artificially forced and awkward.

The segment could be a venue for a dynamic five-person discussion, a la ESPNsAround the Horn.

Instead, each guest critic has barely enough time to deliver a complete thought.

Within the bars are animated shooting stars and other strange oscillating lines, and the effect is flat-out distracting.

Instead of being able to focus on the clip, I couldnt stop staring at those bizarre psychedelic bars.

Devotees ofSiskel & EbertandEbert & Roeper, what do you think of the newAt the Movies?

Do you miss the old hosts, or enjoy this format better?